How to prepare for a debate: a four-step structure for prep time
Jehiel Pather, NSW State Team
· 7 min read
The short answer
Most school debates with a topic released on the day give teams between 45 minutes and an hour to prepare. We teach four steps. First, set up the comparison: what are the two worlds each side is defending? Second, find the biggest impacts in the debate for both sides. Third, work out the key drivers of those impacts and the factors that contribute to them. Fourth, find which of those factors your side's policy can change, and explain how changing them gets you to the impacts. Then make sure the whole team agrees on the same arguments, and write notes on paper: word for word for the complicated parts, dot points for the simple ones.
Most school debates with a topic released on the day give teams between 45 minutes and an hour to prepare. The Premier's Debating Challenge in NSW gives one hour, for example. That's not long, so it helps to have a structure. This is the one we teach: four questions, answered in order.
Step 1: What are the two worlds?
Start by setting up the comparison. Every debate is a contest between two worlds, and before you think of a single argument you need to know what they are. In a policy debate (“That we should…”), it's usually the world with the policy against the world without it. If the affirmative sets out a model, or the negative proposes a counter-model, those define the worlds more precisely (our lesson on models and counter-models explains how).
Getting this right first keeps the whole prep comparative. Every argument you write later is a claim that one of these two worlds is better.
Step 2: What are the biggest impacts, for both sides?
Next, work out what the debate is really about: the biggest impacts on each side. Who or what is most affected, and how? Do this for both teams, not just your own. If you only list the good things about your side, you'll be surprised by the other team's case and you won't know which of your impacts needs to outweigh theirs.
If you're stuck, list the stakeholders the topic affects, as we teach in how to structure an argument, and ask what happens to each of them.
Step 3: What drives those impacts?
For each big impact, ask what causes it. What are the key drivers, and what are the factors that contribute to them? This is the step that turns a list of good and bad outcomes into an explanation of why they happen.
Step 4: What can your side change?
Finally, look at those contributing factors and ask which ones your team's side can actually change, and how changing them gets you to the impacts. This is where your arguments come from. An argument built this way doesn't just say a good thing will happen. It shows the exact factor your policy changes, and why that change leads to the outcome. If you're on the negative, ask the same question of the world you're defending, whether that's the status quo or a counter-model.
Get the team on the same page
Those four steps are the team's internal structure. The next job is communicating it, so that every speaker is aligned on the same arguments. A team whose first speaker frames the debate one way and whose second speaker argues something slightly different gives the other team an easy target. Before anyone starts writing their own speech, agree on the two worlds, the arguments, and who is making each one.
Writing your notes
For high school debating, and even primary school debating, we suggest writing your notes on paper, where the competition allows it. You can fit more on a page, and it's easy to edit: moving a point, adding a response or crossing something out takes a second.
What goes on the page depends on how hard the idea is. When something is complicated, write it word for word, because the exact wording matters and it's easy to get tangled explaining it on the spot. When something is simple, a dot point is enough. That balance lets a speaker explain the hard parts clearly and carefully without spending the whole prep time writing a script. (Writing everything out has its own problems, which we cover in how to get better at debating.)
Practising prep
Prep is a skill like any other, and it gets faster with practice. Every one of our classes includes a live debate, with feedback from the coach on the arguments students built as well as how they delivered them. Class times and prices are on the programs page.
Common questions
- How long do you get to prepare for a debate?
- Most school debates with a topic released on the day allow between 45 minutes and an hour of preparation. The NSW Premier's Debating Challenge, for example, gives teams one hour.
- What should you do first in debate prep?
- Set up the comparison. Work out the two worlds the teams are defending, such as a world with the policy and a world without it, because every argument in the debate is a claim about which world is better.
- What should debaters write their notes on?
- We suggest paper for primary and high school debaters, where the competition allows it. You can fit more on a page, and it's easy to move a point, add a response or cross something out.
- Should I write my debate speech out word for word?
- Only the complicated parts, where the exact wording matters. Write simpler points as dot points. That balances explaining things clearly and carefully with not running out of prep time.