Skip to content

The three most common mistakes new debaters make, and how to fix them

Jehiel Pather, NSW State Team
· 6 min read

The short answer

The three mistakes we see most often are these. Rebuttal doesn't engage with the other team: a speaker answers one argument with a different argument, and both can be true at once. Arguments aren't comparative: the speaker explains why their side is good instead of why it's better than the other side. And claims are possible but not shown to be likely: the speaker explains how something could happen without explaining why it probably will. Each one has a simple test a student can apply in prep.

I've coached and judged a lot of debates, and the same three mistakes come up again and again. None of them is about confidence or how a speaker sounds. They're mistakes in the thinking, which is good news, because each one has a fix a student can learn and check for in prep.

1. Rebuttal that doesn't engage with the other team

This is the most common one. The other team makes an argument, and the speaker responds with an argument of their own about the same subject. It sounds like rebuttal, but the two arguments never meet.

The fix is to make every response engage explicitly with what the other team said. Start by naming their exact claim, then show either that it isn't true or that it doesn't matter as much as they say. An answer that gives a reason the opposite will happen, like the negative's here, can still work. The speaker just has to say why their reason is more likely than the other team's, for example because it happens in more cases.

A quick test in prep: for each response, can you point to the exact sentence of theirs it answers? If not, it's an argument, not rebuttal. Our lesson on how to rebut an argument goes through the four ways to answer one.

2. Forgetting to be comparative

Debating isn't about explaining why your side is good and the other side is bad. It's always about explaining why your side is better than the other side.

That matters because in many debates both sides are defending something reasonable. If the topic is that governments should fund community sport ahead of elite sport, both kinds of sport do real good. A speaker who spends four minutes on the benefits of community sport hasn't touched the question, which is whether those benefits outweigh what elite sport would have delivered with the same money. In other debates both sides defend something with real costs, and the question is which costs are worse.

The fix is to finish every argument with a comparison. Phrases like “this matters more than their point because…” and “compared with their world, ours…” force the speaker to do it. We explain why the adjudicator always compares the two sides in how a debate works.

3. Explaining why something could happen, not why it's likely

This is the biggest problem of the three, and it isn't only a beginner's mistake. Debaters make it all the way from primary school to high school to university. A speaker lays out a chain of events that could happen, and every step is possible, but they never explain why any of it is likely.

The fix is to give reasons each step is likely. Who has a reason to act that way? What's stopping it from happening already? Why does your side's policy change that? An argument that answers those questions is much harder to brush aside. Probability is one of the six measures of weighing in our lesson on how to structure an argument.

How students learn to stop making them

Knowing about a mistake isn't the same as not making it with the clock running. Students fix these by debating, getting feedback that names the specific mistake, and debating again with that one thing in mind. That's why every DebateBetter class includes a live debate and individual feedback from the coach. You can find class times and prices on the programs page.

Common questions

What is the most common mistake in debating?
Rebuttal that doesn't engage with the other team. A speaker answers the other team's argument with a new argument of their own, and because both can be true at the same time, the adjudicator hasn't been given a reason to prefer either.
What does it mean to be comparative in a debate?
It means explaining why your side is better than the other side, not just why your side is good. In some debates both sides defend something good, and in others both defend something with real costs, so the comparison is what decides the debate.
How do you show an argument is likely in a debate?
Give a reason it will happen, not just a way it could. Explain who has a reason to act that way, what's stopping it from happening now, and why your side's policy changes that.
Do experienced debaters make these mistakes too?
Yes. Showing that a claim is likely rather than merely possible is a problem for debaters from primary school all the way through to university.

Start here

Small classes with high-level coaches, every week

Tell us your child's year level and we'll place them in the right term class. Classes have six or fewer students.