How do you get better at debating?
Jehiel Pather, NSW State Team
· 7 min read
The short answer
Getting better at debating comes down to three things: knowledge of the world, knowledge of debating, and practising debates with good feedback. Knowledge of the world comes from reading and regular exercises. Knowledge of debating is the theory of how to build an argument, show it matters more than the other side's, and rebut. Practice works when it comes with feedback specific to the student. At home, parents usually notice their child becoming more confident and more structured. The most common cause of a plateau is memorising speeches word for word instead of understanding why the argument is true.
Parents often ask me what it actually takes to get good at debating. The answer I give is that debating rests on three things, and a student needs all of them: knowledge of the world, knowledge of debating, and practice. A student who is strong on one and weak on the others will hit a ceiling quickly. Here's what each involves and how we build it.
Knowledge of the world
A debater can be given a topic on almost anything: the economy, foreign policy, schools, technology, the environment. With limited time to prepare, what they already know is what they have to work with. A student who understands how governments, markets and institutions work will think of better arguments, and explain them more convincingly, than one who doesn't.
We build this deliberately. Students get homework, practice on our Drill app and other exercises, all aimed at learning more about the world. For a lot of students this ends up being one of the most rewarding parts of debating. They start reading the news differently, and they find subjects they didn't know they cared about.
Knowledge of debating
The second thing is debating theory: how to construct an argument, how to explain why one argument is more important than another, and how to rebut. This is what our coaches teach in the workshops that are part of both private lessons and group classes, and what students practise in Drill between classes.
The theory can be as simple or as complex as the student is ready for. A student in their first term might learn that every argument has to show why it's true and why it's important. A student preparing for state trials might be learning how to weigh two arguments that matter in completely different ways. Both are working on the same skill at a different depth. Our lessons on structuring an argument and rebuttal give a sense of what this looks like.
Practice, with feedback
The third thing is debating itself, and getting feedback on it. This is where the first two come together, and it's also where coaching has to become individual. The issues students have, and the strengths they can build on, are different for every student. One speaker needs to slow down and structure their speech. Another has great structure and needs to explain why their claims are likely. Generic feedback doesn't help either of them.
So we focus on giving lots of good feedback: specific to that student, about what to change next time. Every class includes a live debate, so students can put the feedback to work straight away.
What you'll notice at home
What parents usually notice is their child becoming more confident, and also more structured. They explain their views with reasons, in an order, and they're more likely to respond to what you actually said than to talk past it.
Why students plateau: memorising
The most common habit that holds a student back is believing they need to write their speech out word for word, or memorise it before they give it. It feels safe, but it causes two problems. In debating there is limited time to prepare, so there usually isn't time to write and learn a script. And memorising stops a student understanding their own argument. They know the words, but not why the words are true.
What matters is understanding why what you're saying is true: knowing the structure of the argument, and the key causes, drivers and impacts you're claiming. A student who knows those can explain the argument in whatever words come, answer a question about it, and defend it when the other team attacks it.
How parents can help
You don't need any debating background to help. The most useful thing you can do is encourage intellectual curiosity. Help your child find things to read about subjects that interest them, ideally things that also teach them how the world works. That builds the first of the three foundations without feeling like homework.
The other is to foster the habit of asking why. One of the best signs of a future debater is a child who keeps asking why things are the way they are. Encourage it, and encourage them to try to understand why something works the way it does rather than accepting it at face value. That habit is the start of every good argument.
Where we fit
Our classes cover all three foundations every week: practice in Drill between classes, a workshop on debating theory, and a live debate with individual feedback. Group classes are online, with six or fewer students, at $50 an hour per student ($100 a two-hour class). Private coaching is $150 an hour. You can see class times on the programs page.
Common questions
- What skills do you need to be good at debating?
- Three things: knowledge of the world, so you have something to say about any topic; knowledge of debating, meaning how to build arguments, weigh them and rebut; and practice, with feedback on your own strengths and weaknesses.
- Should my child memorise their debate speech?
- No. Debates leave limited time to prepare, and memorising stops a student understanding what they're saying. It's more useful to know the structure and the key causes, drivers and impacts of each argument, so they can explain why it's true in their own words.
- What changes will I notice as my child gets better at debating?
- Most parents notice their child becoming more confident and more structured, both when they speak and in how they explain their views.
- How can I help my child get better at debating at home?
- Encourage intellectual curiosity. Help them read about things that interest them and teach them about the world, and encourage them to ask why things are the way they are rather than accepting things at face value.