Skip to content

How are school debates marked? Matter, manner and method explained

Jehiel Pather, NSW State Team
· 7 min read

The short answer

Australian school debates are judged on matter (the arguments and rebuttal), manner (how the speech is delivered) and method (structure, timing and responsiveness to the debate). Under the Australian Debating Federation's guide and the Debaters Association of Victoria's scoring, each speech is marked out of 100: 40 for matter, 40 for manner and 20 for method, with 75 as the expected standard for the grade. World Schools debating uses the same 40/40/20 split under the names content, style and strategy. Adjudicators judge as an average reasonable person, and the marks are there to support their decision about which team persuaded better.

Parents often come away from a school debate unsure why one team won. Both sides seemed confident, both had arguments, and the adjudicator talked for five minutes about things like “engagement” and “weighing.” This guide explains what adjudicators are actually assessing. It draws on the Australian Debating Federation's Australia-Asia Debating Guide (second edition), the Debaters Association of Victoria's published scoring, and the World Schools Debating Championships rules. Each competition sets its own rules, so check the one your child is in.

Who is the adjudicator supposed to be?

The Australia-Asia Debating Guide asks the adjudicator to take the role of an average reasonable person: someone with ordinary knowledge of the topic, but expert knowledge of the rules of debating. They have to set aside their own views on the topic and any specialist knowledge they have. An adjudicator who is an economist shouldn't mark down an economic argument because they know a detail the students didn't.

The guide also draws a useful line between an adjudicator and an audience member. The audience asks “was I persuaded?” The adjudicator asks which team better performed the process of persuasion, under the rules of debate. The guide says adjudicators should not award a tie.

Matter: what is said

Matter is the content of the speech: arguments, evidence, examples and analysis, including rebuttal and, where they are used, points of information. The guide names two elements, logic (does the conclusion follow from the premise?) and relevance (does the argument add weight to what the team needs to prove?).

Two rules in this category surprise students. First, a weak argument stays weak whether or not the other team points it out, so a team can't rely on its opponents missing a gap. Second, examples support an argument but don't replace it. The guide warns against debates that turn into two teams reading out lists of examples, and compares a team's case to a tree: the topic is the trunk, the arguments are branches, the examples are leaves. Shaking off a few leaves doesn't bring the tree down. We teach how to attack the branches in how to rebut an argument.

Manner: how it is said

Manner is the delivery: body language and vocal style. The guide accepts that it is the most subjective category and gives adjudicators one test: did this aspect of the speaker's style add to or take away from the force of their arguments? There is no rule that loud is better than quiet, or that speaking without notes beats using them. The DAV's own explanation covers voice, body language, notes, eye contact, humour, volume and pace, with the aim of being persuasive.

For parents of quieter children this is reassuring. A calm, clear speaker can score well on manner. What costs marks is delivery that gets in the way: reading word for word with no eye contact, speaking so fast the adjudicator can't keep up, or losing the thread.

Method: how the speech and the team are organised

Method is structure and organisation. It includes whether each speaker fulfils their role, how they manage time, how the team divides its arguments, and how well speakers adapt to what happens in the debate. The guide names two elements, responsiveness and structure, and is clear that adjudicators should judge how well a duty was done, not just whether it was done. A definition that exists but sets up a bad debate doesn't earn method marks simply for being there. The roles themselves are in how a school debate works.

How the marks are split

The Australia-Asia Debating Guide and the DAV both mark each speech out of 100, split 40 for matter, 40 for manner and 20 for method. Both treat 75 as a speech at the expected standard for that grade, which is why scores cluster in a narrow band. World Schools uses the same split under different names. The published ranges differ a little:

Australia-Asia Debating Guide (ADF)Debaters Association of VictoriaWorld Schools (WSDC rules)
CategoriesMatter 40, manner 40, method 20Matter 40, manner 40, method 20Content 40, style 40, strategy 20
Expected or average speech75 (30, 30, 15)75 (30, 30, 15)70 (28, 28, 14)
Matter or manner range26 to 3427 to 3324 to 32
Method range13 to 1713 to 1712 to 16
Speech total65 to 85, most between 70 and 80Not stated as a total60 to 80
Reply speechesOut of 50 (20, 20, 10)Not covered on the scoring pageOut of 50 (20, 20, 10)

Not every competition publishes its scheme. The NSW Arts Unit's page for the Premier's Debating Challenge, for instance, sets out the format and rules but not a mark breakdown. It says the adjudicator's decision is final and that adjudicators are usually available afterwards to explain it.

Do the marks decide the debate?

Not on their own. The guide says the adjudicator makes the decision and the marks should reflect it. If the totals point one way and the adjudicator's overall impression points the other, they go back through their notes to find out which is wrong. One common error it names is letting a strong final speech overshadow everything that came before. World Schools judges are trained the same way: the WSDC judge training says the team with the higher total must win, so if the totals and the judge's final impression disagree, the judge revises the scores.

The margin tells you something too. Under the guide, a margin of 1 to 4 marks is a very close debate, 5 to 9 is a relatively clear decision, and 10 or more means the losing team probably failed in one or more fundamental parts of its argument or presentation.

Common reasons teams lose

From our own coaching and adjudicating, and in line with what the guide asks adjudicators to look for, these are the problems that decide most school debates.

  • No real clash. The guide says rebuttal is what separates debating from public speaking. A team that delivers its prepared case and barely responds hasn't engaged.
  • Rebutting everything equally. Going point by point through every argument and example leaves no time for the issue that matters. The guide prefers rebuttal aimed at the important strategic issues.
  • Not weighing. Showing your argument is true isn't enough; the team has to explain why it matters more than the other side's.
  • New material from the last speaker. The final negative speaker may not bring in new arguments. The guide says the adjudicator simply doesn't credit it, and it can cost method marks too.
  • Timing. Material delivered well past the time limit (the guide allows about 30 seconds of leeway) earns no matter marks, and a speech that ends before the warning bell usually loses method marks.
  • Arguing the wrong debate. The guide calls it an invalid case when a team's arguments, even if true, don't actually answer the topic. Negative teams that guessed the affirmative case wrongly in prep are the usual victims.
  • Not adapting. If the other team concedes a point, spending time proving it is a strategic error. Teams that stick rigidly to their prep notes lose method marks.

What the adjudicator's oral feedback means

At the end of most debates the adjudicator explains the result out loud. The Australia-Asia Debating Guide asks them to highlight the critical differences between the teams rather than replay the whole debate, often by focusing on the one or two issues the debate was won or lost on. By the end, debaters should know clearly why they won or lost. The WSDC rules ask for the same thing: a short adjudication that sets out the key reasons the winning team won, delivered constructively.

That means the adjudication is a summary, not a full report. The DAV encourages adjudicators to keep oral adjudications under ten minutes and notes there is no rule that they must comment on every speaker. A student who wants feedback on their own speech should ask afterwards, politely. When an adjudicator says a team “didn't engage” or “didn't weigh,” they usually mean the team argued past the other side, or never explained why its points outweighed theirs. If feedback seems to contradict something a coach said, the DAV's advice is to ask the adjudicator to clarify.

The habit worth building is to write down the reason for the decision straight after every debate, win or lose, and look at it before the next one.

How we use this in coaching

Several of our coaches adjudicate at a senior level. Jade Di Girolamo is Chief Adjudicator of the Australian Intervarsity Debating Championship 2027, Jehiel Pather was Deputy Chief Adjudicator of the Australian Intervarsity Debating Championship 2026, and Jack Glass has been Deputy Chief Adjudicator of the Australian National Debating Championship. Their profiles are on the coaches page. In our online classes of six or fewer, each class includes a live debate with feedback from the coach. Group classes are $50 per student per hour, so $100 for each two-hour class, and private coaching is $150 per hour. Details are on the programs page. If your child is heading towards representative debating, our guide to the World Schools format covers the version used at international level.

Common questions

What is matter, manner and method in debating?
Matter is what a speaker says: their arguments, evidence, examples and rebuttal. Manner is how they say it, including voice and body language. Method is the structure and timing of the speech and how well it responds to what is happening in the debate.
How many marks is a debating speech out of?
Under the Australian Debating Federation's Australia-Asia Debating Guide and the Debaters Association of Victoria's scoring, 100: 40 for matter, 40 for manner and 20 for method. Reply speeches, where a competition uses them, are marked out of 50.
What is a good debating score?
A speech at the expected standard for the grade scores 75. The Australia-Asia Debating Guide says most speeches fall between 70 and 80, and the DAV keeps matter and manner between 27 and 33 and method between 13 and 17. A score is relative to the grade, so 75 in Year 7 and 75 in a senior final mean different things.
Can a team win if the other team spoke better?
Yes. Manner is only one of three categories, and adjudicators decide which team better performed the process of persuasion overall. A team with stronger arguments and sharper rebuttal can beat a more polished team that didn't engage.
Can you appeal an adjudicator's decision in a school debate?
Usually the decision stands. The NSW Arts Unit, for example, says the adjudicator's decision in the Premier's Debating Challenge is final. Students can still ask the adjudicator afterwards to explain their reasoning, which is often the most useful part of the debate.

Start here

Small classes with high-level coaches, every week

Tell us your child's year level and we'll place them in the right term class. Classes have six or fewer students.